Almost perfect person, but not able to proceed.

Is it common? I (26F) got a match (30M). The guy ticks every check from family background, astrology, caste, job, height almost same, conventionally good looking-ish, progressive mindset and every other thing. But am not able to proceed. Like just something about this person that is making me not feel attracted to them. We haven’t started talking yet. And I am struggling to give reasons to my parents as to why I don’t want this person. And even am not sure why. And am not talking about physical attractiveness. Or maybe I am? But i sent the pic to my friends and they say he is good looking. Yes, conventionally good looking, but am not feeling that attraction. Am not talking about some movie style sweep me off my feet or anything. Just that I don’t see this person as my person for some reason. Is this common? Just a feeling that this is not the person for me or something?