Help Picking Out A Leather

Hello everyone, I could use some advice on picking a leather. The boot has already been decided as the Americana.

Use: Everyday boot with some light hiking (think one shoe for a vacation)

I have a lot of regular brown shoes (brown CXL/double shot brown)

Thinking of: 1964 Mahogany Roughout, Predator Orange, CXL Black, Cypress 8.

I’d love a durable leather that I don’t have to baby if I’m going in a hike, or worry about my children stepping on my shoes, but one that would also look nice enough for a semi-nice dinner.